Stop by Forty Carrots in Bloomingdale’s at 59th Street and Lexington Avenue 1000 Third Avenue New York NY 10022. Forty Carrots is a cafe that serves frozen yogurt, sandwiches, and salads, offers excellent service and has a great atmosphere. After a long shopping spree at Bloomingdale’s 59th street, is there a more perfect way to unwind than grabbing a bite at Forty Carrots? We think not. With so many wonderful choices, Forty Carrots is a real treat - and you deserve it!